New HoP: Milgram, Murray, Nostalgia, and More!

The August 2013 issue of History of Psychology is now online. Included in this issues are articles that look at the history of the concept of nostalgia, the contingencies surrounding the voice-feedback condition in Stanley Milgram’s obedience to authority experiments, a translation of Wilhelm Wundt’s (above) Psychology’s Struggle for Existence (Die Psychologie im Kampf ums Dasein) by James Lamiell, and the correspondence between American psychologist Henry Murray and Chinese psychologist Siegen K. Chou. Other items in this issue explore strategies in writing books in the history of psychology and developments in history and philsophy of psychology in Brazil. Full titles, authors and abstracts follow below.

“Nostalgia: The bittersweet history of a psychological concept,” by Krystine Irene Batcho. The abstract reads,

The concept of nostalgia has changed substantially both denotatively and connotatively over the span of its 300-year history. This article traces the evolution of the concept from its origins as a medical disease to its contemporary understanding as a psychological construct. The difficulty of tracing a construct through history is highlighted. Attention is paid to roles played first by the medical context, and then by the psychiatric, psychoanalytic, and psychological approaches. Emphasis is given to shifts in the designation of nostalgic valence from bitter to sweet to bittersweet, and the processes of semantic drift and depathologization are explored. Because the sense of nostalgia was constructed and reconstructed within social, cultural, and historical contexts, its meaning changed along with the words used to describe and connect it to other entities. Nostalgia’s past illustrates the influence of language, social-cultural context, and discipline perspectives on how a construct is defined, researched, and applied.

““The last possible resort”: A forgotten prod and the in situ standardization of Stanley Milgram’s voice-feedback condition,” Stephen Gibson. The abstract reads,

This article uses previously unpublished data from Stanley Milgram’s obedience experiments to draw attention to a hitherto neglected procedural innovation of the voice-feedback condition. In 3 experimental sessions in this condition, the experimenter responded to a participant’s attempted defiance by leaving the room, apparently to speak to the learner, before returning to assure the participant that the learner was willing or able to continue. This article documents the use of this tactic during the voice-feedback condition and highlights the negotiation surrounding the use of the tactic between Milgram and his confederate John Williams, who played the role of the experimenter. It is shown that the subsequent use of this tactic did not conform to the conditions for its use agreed by Milgram and Williams. Moreover, the tactic seems to have been dropped from both subsequent experimental conditions and Milgram’s published accounts of his work. These observations are discussed in relation to historical work on experimentation in social psychology, research on standardization in the sociology of scientific knowledge, and in terms of their implications for theory and research on dis/obedience.

“Translator’s preface,” James T. Lamiell. The abstract reads,

Presents a preface from James T. Lamiell, who translates Wilhelm Wundt’s Psychology’s Struggle for Existence (Die Psychologie im Kampf ums Dasein), in which Wundt advised against the impending divorce of psychology from philosophy, into English. Lamiell comments that more than a decade into the 21st century, it appears that very few psychologists have any interest at all in work at the interface of psychology and philosophy. He notes that one clear indication of this is that the Society for Theoretical and Philosophical Psychology, which is Division 24 of the American Psychological Association (APA), remains one of the smallest of the APA’s nearly 60 divisions.

“Psychology’s struggle for existence: Second edition, 1913,” by Wilhelm Wundt and James T. Lamiell (Trans). The abstract reads,

Presents an English translation of Wilhelm Wundt’s Psychology’s struggle for existence: Second edition, 1913, by James T. Lamiell in August, 2012. In his essay, Wundt advised against the impending divorce of psychology from philosophy.

“Correspondence between Henry A. Murray and Siegen K. Chou,” by Shu-Chang Yan and Jing Chen. The abstract reads,

Siegen K. Chou received his PhD under the supervision of Walter R. Miles and conducted psychological research in China afterward. During 1930–1949, he kept close communication and cooperated with American psychologists. In 1945, Chou and his colleagues cooperated with Murray, Lyman, and others to test paratroop candidates for the Chinese Nationalist Army. Correspondence between Henry A. Murray and Siegen K. Chou, which reveals their friendship and cooperation relation to Chou’s goal to develop Chinese psychology, was reviewed briefly.

“Shaping and owning the boundaries of a book,” by Cheryl A. Logan. The abstract reads,

Cheryl Logan uses examples from her recent book, Hormones, Heredity, and Race, to discuss the importance of establishing conceptual boundaries, as writers develop book projects. The conceptual clarity of a book’s central thesis and transitions to key subthemes that enrich its structure can both benefit from well-crafted edges that exclude some topics.

“The Wilhelm Wundt Center and the first graduate program for the history and philosophy of psychology in Brazil: A brief report,” by Saulo de Freitas Araujo, Fátima Siqueira Caropreso, Richard Theisen Simanke, and Gustavo Arja Castañon. The abstract reads,

The expansion of Brazilian universities since 2009 has promoted a general growth and incentive of scientific activities throughout the country, not only in the so-called hard sciences, but also in the human sciences. In this brief report, we announce the creation of two new institutional spaces dedicated to the history and philosophy of psychology at the Federal University of Juiz de Fora (UFJF) in Brazil: the Wilhelm Wundt Center for the History and Philosophy of Psychology (NUHFIP) and the Graduate Program in History and Philosophy of Psychology.

About Jacy Young

Jacy Young is a professor at Quest University Canada. A critical feminist psychologist and historian of psychology, she is committed to critical pedagogy and public engagement with feminist psychology and the history of the discipline.

1 thought on “New HoP: Milgram, Murray, Nostalgia, and More!

Comments are closed.